Share this article:
Who better to talk about the evolution of search than someone who has spent more than two decades documenting its biggest developments?
For many of us in the SEO industry, publications like Search Engine Roundtable and Search Engine Land have been valuable resources for understanding the fundamentals of search, keeping up with Google updates, and learning how the industry evolves. They have also been part of my own journey as I grew in this field.
I had the opportunity to speak with Barry Schwartz, President of RustyBrick, Inc. and Owner, RustyBrick, Inc., and contributing editor at Search Engine Land.
In this conversation, we explore SEO myths and misconceptions, Google’s influence, content quality, AI search, and what the future holds for the industry. His answers are refreshingly direct, sometimes provocative, and certainly worth exploring.
Who Is Barry Schwartz?
Barry Schwartz is a technology entrepreneur and veteran search industry journalist who has spent more than two decades covering the developments shaping the search landscape.
With more than two decades of experience covering the search industry, Barry has witnessed Google’s evolution, major algorithm updates, and the transformation of search from traditional results to AI-powered experiences.
He is the founder of Search Engine Roundtable, launched in 2003, where he reports on Google updates, search engine developments, and discussions within the SEO community.
He is also the CEO of RustyBrick, a technology company founded in 1994 that specializes in building custom web and mobile applications for businesses.
In addition, Barry serves as a contributing editor at Search Engine Land, sharing insights and reporting on Google’s developments and the wider search marketing industry.
The Interview
The Journey: Technology, Search, and Business
Q, You founded RustyBrick and built a career around search and technology. What initially drew you to SEO, and how did that interest evolve into building your own company?
Barry Schwartz:
RustyBrick came in 1994, well before I started the Search Engine Roundtable in 2023. I love building stuff with technology. So that is why we started RustyBrick. But when search engines started to come up on the web, I found the SEO industry fascinating. The mystery to it, early on… The way things changed so fast. The way the community always helped each other out… It is a great industry.
Q. What has been the biggest challenge in running an SEO and web development business in an industry where search algorithms, technologies, and client expectations constantly change?
Barry Schwartz:
That is the beauty of the industry – the change. The technology is always updating, always adapting. And now with AI, things are moving even fast. I love change.
Q, Looking back at your journey, is there a business or SEO decision that fundamentally changed the direction of your career?
Barry Schwartz:
AI is a big one. Most of my team now doesn’t code by hand anymore. They just prompt all day. Which is wild.
SEO Strategy: What Really Influences Rankings?
Q. Can a website with excellent content and strong technical SEO still fail to rank? What factors do SEO professionals frequently underestimate?
Barry Schwartz:
Yes. I mean, it can be on a spammy domain they just acquired. There could be a weird technical glitch causing the issue. But generally, if your content is the best and your technical SEO is good, you should rank.
Q. What SEO practice is widely accepted as a best practice but, in your experience, delivers little or no measurable value?
Barry Schwartz:
core web vitals
Content Marketing and Topical Authority
Q. Can a website rank successfully without following the conventional SEO content structure of H1s, H2s, FAQs, and keyword placement?
Barry Schwartz:
Yes.
Q. Are we creating too much content? Has the pressure to publish consistently resulted in an internet saturated with repetitive, interchangeable articles?
Barry Schwartz:
Probably yes, 🙂
AI Search and the Future of SEO
Q. If users increasingly receive answers directly from AI search engines without visiting websites, what exactly should SEO professionals optimize for?
Barry Schwartz:
The new thing to optimize for, outside of getting a click is making sure your brand or website is mentioned in the AI answer.
Q. Can a brand have strong AI search visibility but declining organic traffic? How should businesses measure the value of that visibility?
Barry Schwartz:
Yes, that is what is happening now with AI Overviews on Google. Many searchers just read the AI Overview and do not click over to the site, so organic traffic is declining but impressions in Google Search for that brand increases or stays the same. Many are measuring brand visibility in search.
Q. Suppose an AI search engine consistently recommends your competitor but never mentions your brand, despite your website having better organic rankings. How would you investigate the discrepancy?
Barry Schwartz:
It is a content play, you would need to feed it new content or adjust your current content.
Q. If AI search platforms begin citing your content without sending visitors to your website, who benefits more: the publisher or the AI platform?
Barry Schwartz:
The AI platform.
5. Technical SEO and Real-World Challenges
Q. When a website experiences a sudden organic traffic decline, how do you distinguish an algorithm-related issue from technical problems, seasonality, or changing search demand?
Barry Schwartz:
Google has a good blog post on that. Google’s guide to debugging search traffic drops
Q. When should an SEO professional challenge a developer’s technical implementation, even if the website appears to be functioning perfectly for users?
Barry Schwartz:
If they can prove it is not? Use the URL Inspection tool.
Q. What is one technical SEO improvement you would refuse to implement, even if an automated audit tool flagged it as a critical issue?
Barry Schwartz:
Pruning content, I won’t remove old stories from my site – there is history there. That is for my site, but I guess for other sites, pruning can help…
7. SEO Challenges and Industry Perspectives
Q. If a competitor consistently outranks you despite having weaker content, would you investigate their website, their brand, their audience, or something entirely different?
Barry Schwartz:
I dont tend to focus on competitors but I don’t do SEO.
Q. If your best-performing article generates significant traffic but attracts the wrong audience, would you consider it a successful piece of content?
Barry Schwartz:
No.
Q. How do you distinguish genuinely useful content from content that simply appears comprehensive because it covers every possible subtopic?
Barry Schwartz:
Does it help the user.
9. The Final Word: An Unpopular SEO Truth
Q. What is one thing about SEO that you believe most professionals in the industry get wrong?
Barry Schwartz:
google ads influence google organic rankings
My Takeaway
What stood out to me in this conversation was Barry’s straightforward perspective on the changing search landscape. His observations on AI search, content quality, and Google’s influence reinforce one thing: the industry needs to look beyond rankings and clicks.
As digital marketers, we must pay attention to how people discover information, how brands gain visibility, and whether the content we create genuinely helps our audience.
About Beyond Rankings
Beyond Rankings is an interview series by Simply Sansu featuring conversations with industry professionals, thought leaders, and experienced practitioners across SEO, digital marketing, technology, and public relations.
Through these conversations, I aim to explore industry perspectives, challenge conventional assumptions, and understand the developments shaping the future of digital marketing.
The goal is simple: go beyond rankings and discover the people, experiences, and ideas influencing the industry.
Connect with Barry Schwartz
Want to follow Barry’s work and keep up with the latest developments in search?
Explore his publications and company:
- Search Engine Roundtable: https://www.seroundtable.com/
- Search Engine Land: https://searchengineland.com/
- RustyBrick: https://www.rustybrick.com/
- Personal website: https://www.barryschwartz.org/
- LinkedIn Profile: https://www.linkedin.com/in/rustybrick/
Coming Up Next
Stay tuned for the next edition of Beyond Rankings, featuring Igor (Doctor Ads) Ivitskiy, PhD in Mathematics, internationally recognized PPC expert, international speaker, and Google Ads specialist with over $770 million in advertising spend managed. We’ll be exploring his perspectives on PPC, Google Ads, and the evolving world of paid search.


